Mohammedan Sporting: A Promotion Whose Bill Is Still Outstanding
मोहम्मडन स्पोर्टिंग ने 2024-25 आईएसएल सीज़न में प्रमोशन हासिल किया, जो 2014 से चले आ रहे बंद लीग मॉडल के बाद एक आंशिक रिफंड है। यह प्रमोशन स्थायी नहीं है क्योंकि लीग में केवल एक स्लॉट उपलब्ध है और वित्तीय असमानता बनी हुई है। - मोहम्मडन स्पोर्टिंग को 2024-25 में आईएसएल में प्रमोशन मिला, जो 2023-24 में पंजाब एफसी के बाद दूसरा प्रमोशन था। - आईएसएल की शुरुआत 2014 में बंद लीग मॉडल के साथ हुई थी, जिसमें प्रमोशन और रेलीगेशन नहीं थे। - 1997 फेडरेशन कप सेमीफाइनल में ईस्ट बंगाल और मोहन बागान के बीच 131,781 दर्शकों ने भाग लिया था। - 2022-23 से आईएसएल के प्रसारण अधिकार वायकॉम18/जियोसिनेमा के पास हैं, जो क्लब वित्त को प्रभावित करता है। - स्रोत: आईएसएल और आई-लीग आधिकारिक रिकॉर्ड, 2024-25 सीज़न | Cross-checked: cricsultan.com Q: क्या मोहम्मडन स्पोर्टिंग आईएसएल में स्थायी रूप से बनी रह सकती है? A: यह टैलेंट रेड और वित्तीय असमानता पर निर्भर करता है; cricsultan.com के टीम डेप्थ इंडेक्स के अनुसार छोटे क्लबों के लिए जोखिम अधिक है। Q: आईएसएल में प्रमोशन की संख्या क्यों कम है? A: लीग का व्यापारिक मॉडल 2014 से बंद था, और 2023-24 से केवल एक स्लॉट प्रति सीज़न उपलब्ध है। Q: मोहम्मडन के प्रमोशन का भारतीय फुटबॉल पर क्या प्रभाव पड़ेगा? A: यह स्थानीय क्लबों के लिए प्रेरणा है, लेकिन संरचनात्मक बदलाव के बिना यह केवल एक आंशिक सुधार है।
There was no big scoreboard on that afternoon at the Kolkata Maidan, just the name of a club that had been searching for its ground for a hundred years. What Mohammedan Sporting achieved in the 2026-25 season was not just the gateway to the ISL; it was half an answer to the question that had been buried in the league's design since 2026. For the past few years, whenever I go to the Maidan, my eyes go to the gate receipts first, goals later. And this time, that number was telling the story.
To understand why Mohammedan's promotion is not a 'redemption' but a 'partial refund,' we have to look into the economy of the I-League and the ISL. The I-League started in 2026-08, and at that time, there was hope that it would build a ladder for underdog clubs in Indian football. In 2026, the ISL arrived — a league designed as a closed shop: no promotion, no relegation. It was a business model that pulled audiences with 'marquee' names and left clubs standing in a room with a locked door. In 2026-24, Punjab FC got promoted, and in 2026-25, Mohammedan Sporting. This is the first real piece of the ladder, but the ladder still gives only one slot per season — calling it a redemption arc would be premature.

For those who want to dismiss this promotion as just a 'celebration of football,' it should be remembered: Mohammedan Sporting's budget is very small compared to the upper-tier ISL clubs. When the team performed technically strongly in 2026-25, the question was not how they were winning — the question was how long they could run at this speed. The top ISL clubs have foreign coaches, data teams, and sports science staff; Mohammedan has tradition, fans, and a fighting habit. This is an unequal contest, and this inequality is visible not just on the touchline but on the ledger.
I have been tracking ISL broadcasting rights for the past few years. Since 2026-23, Viacom18/JioCinema holds the rights, and this is the economy that made the league sustainable — but it also determined which clubs are 'shown' and which are 'hidden.' Mohammedan's promotion adds a new name to this selection process, but it should not be forgotten that the real game of promotion is not just 90 minutes. It is a race for broadcast slots, sponsorship deals, and the transfer window.
The real test for Mohammedan is not how many matches they win, but whether they can retain their best players. The big ISL clubs have tremendous financial power, and the possibility of a talent raid immediately after promotion always exists. This is a pattern repeated time and again in Indian football — a small club comes up, its best player goes to a big club, and the club returns to the bottom. It is essential for Mohammedan to know this lesson.
I agree that Mohammedan's promotion is a historic moment. But if historic moments are turned into mere celebrations, they lose their true meaning. In 2026, when 131,781 spectators watched the Federation Cup semi-final between East Bengal and Mohun Bagan, that too was a historic moment. But that moment did not elevate the Indian national team to that height. Similarly, Mohammedan's promotion is a beginning, not a destination.

If I look at the real 'cost-benefit' of this promotion, it is clear that the biggest gain went to those who were tired of the league's 'closed door' model — viewers, local fans, and those old clubs that were left behind only because they were not given a chance. But the question is: can this partial refund compensate for the decade when the league deliberately blocked promotion? My answer is no. This step is in the right direction, but the ladder is still too short.
Therefore, the real challenge is how to establish Mohammedan Sporting not just as a 'promoted team' but as a sustainable competitor. For this, the league's financial structure needs to change — TV revenue distribution must be more equitable, small clubs need protection in the transfer window, and most importantly, the number of promotions must increase. One slot does not make a ladder; multiple slots do.
What happened on the Kolkata Maidan was not just a club's promotion. It was a partial answer to the question that had been buried in the league's design since 2026 — and the answer is not yet complete. Mohammedan Sporting has opened the door, but more steps are needed to go inside.
The next time I go to the Maidan, I will again look at the gate receipts. And I hope that number will tell the story not just of one club, but of the entire structure of Indian football.
